On 7 October 2026, the General Court of the European Union issued a judgment in Case T-529/25 on a request for a preliminary ruling from the Antwerp Court of Appeal. The General Court held that components need not be presented to customs at the same time to be classified under the same tariff heading as a complete article. This applies even when separate shipments are spread over several months.
The General Court’s interpretation does not appear to be fully in line with earlier case law. The First Advocate-General has proposed that the Court of Justice review the judgment under Article 62 of the Statute of the Court of Justice of the European Union. That provision allows for review where there is a serious risk of the unity or consistency of EU law being affected.
Background to Case T-529/25
Definitive anti-dumping and countervailing duties on electric bicycles from China, applicable to complete bicycles but not to their parts, had been in force since January 2019. Between 22 January 2019 and 27 April 2021, a Belgian importer filed 27 import declarations through its customs representative for electric bicycle frames, forks, motors and other parts originating in China, declaring them as parts rather than complete bicycles. The case concerned parts of an electric bicycle invoiced by two different suppliers, transported in different containers and declared by the same declarant for the same consignee at the same customs office over a period of up to several months.
The European Public Prosecutor’s Office and the Belgian customs authorities took the view that this import pattern was designed to avoid payment of more than EUR 2.9 million in anti-dumping and countervailing duties and brought criminal and civil proceedings against the importer and its director.
The General Court’s reasoning
Rule 2(a) of the General Rules for the Interpretation of the Combined Nomenclature provides: “Any reference in a heading to an article shall be taken to include a reference to that article incomplete or unfinished, provided that, as presented, the incomplete or unfinished article has the essential character of the complete or finished article. It shall also be taken to include a reference to that article complete or finished (or falling to be classified as complete or finished by virtue of this rule), presented unassembled or disassembled.”
The General Court held that simultaneous presentation of components to customs is only one relevant indication, not a necessary condition, for classifying them as a complete article under that rule. Parts imported in separate shipments, even months apart and from different suppliers, must be classified as a complete product whenever objective factors show that those parts form a whole and comprise the essential components of that product.
Potential implications if the judgment is upheld
If the General Court’s interpretation is upheld, it would confirm a broader approach to tariff classification. Under that approach, components could fall under the same tariff heading as the finished product they are intended to form, even if invoiced by different suppliers, shipped separately, declared separately or imported over several weeks or months. The General Court’s test is whether objective factors, verifiable at customs clearance, show that the components form a whole, are intended to be assembled into one article and include all of that article’s essential parts. Simultaneous presentation is only one such factor, not a requirement.
In our view, the judgment does not appear to be fully in line with earlier case law: in Osram (183/73), Develop Dr. Eisbein (C-35/93) and X and Inspecteur van de Belastingdienst Douane (C-107/22), the Court of Justice held that components had to be presented to customs at the same time to be regarded as a disassembled or unassembled article. The General Court referred to those judgments but reached the opposite result, reasoning that Court of Justice had never actually been asked to decide that specific question.
If the General Court’s ruling stands, importers may need to reassess their current practices. Pending the outcome of the review process, companies with similar import and assembly models should identify their potential exposure, review the documentation supporting their customs classification practices and the commercial rationale for separate shipments, and consider whether to seek binding tariff information.
The stakes in getting tariff classification right are not only financial. We are increasingly concerned that customs authorities in different EU Member States, including Finland, are more readily initiating criminal proceedings against a company’s management where they consider that an incorrect tariff heading has been used in customs declarations.
Should the ruling be upheld, this risk may be particularly relevant because its classification test relies on an overall assessment of objective factors rather than clear-cut criteria. Such a test could allow customs authorities to assess the same import pattern differently from the importer at the time, potentially exposing genuine assembly operations to the same scrutiny as circumvention. Even where proceedings do not result in a conviction, being investigated and prosecuted is itself a lengthy and burdensome process for a company and the individuals involved.
HPP will continue to follow the proceedings and assess what the final outcome means for importers and EU assembly operations. Further guidance on the ruling’s practical implications will depend on how the Court of Justice addresses the proposed review.